BY CALIFORNIA SCHOLARS FOR ACADEMIC FREEDOM
April 23, 2018
Dear President Castro,
The California Scholars for Academic Freedom, a group of over 200 academics from California institutions of higher education focused on protecting academic freedom and freedom of expression, is writing to express our deep concern over your most recent response to Professor Randa Jarrar’s twitter statements. Professor Jarrar had used her private twitter account to express her opinion about a matter of public concern, the death of the former first lady Barbara Bush.
Professor Jarrar’s statements were made on her personal twitter account while she was on leave from her teaching position. As you correctly acknowledged in your first statement, she spoke as a private citizen about a matter of public interest. This was well within her protected speech as a citizen.
As pointed out by the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, the fact “that her speech offended some or many is not a lawful basis to penalize its expression. Speech cannot be restricted because of its offensive nature.” https://www.thefire.org/fresno-state-university-wont-and-cannot-punish-professor-for-barbara-bush-tweets/ It is alarming that you changed your position on April 18, 2018, in response to public complaints, by stating that Professor Jarrar’s comments went “beyond free speech” for being “disrespectful,” thereby implying that they were not protected speech. Even more concerning were your comment that “a professor with tenure does not have blanket protection to say and do what they wish” and Provost Zelezny’s assertions that Professor Jarrar will be investigated for her comments on twitter and “termination is not out of the question.” /2018/coalition-of-civil-liberties-organizations-to-fresno-state-first-amendment-doesnt-have-a-disrespectful-exception/
Legally and ethically, Professor Jarrar’s commentary is protected speech and a public university cannot punish protected speech. In a vibrant democracy, public commentary is often unpopular and may even be construed as disrespectful and offensive to some yet it is not to be censored, in any way, in any circumstance, and least of all in a university. On the contrary, university administrators should make it their foremost mission to resist public pressures to limit free speech rights of their faculty, precisely because they are in charge of an institution in which free speech and academic freedom intersect in ways that benefit and nourish the society.
It is therefore your responsibility to explain to the public that professor Jarrar’s speech is protected by the First Amendment and the liberty of speech clause of the California Constitution, by which Fresno State is legally bound. Faculty and students on your campus need to feel confident that your administration supports and protects their free speech, as is the case in all public universities.
We join the civil rights organizations in calling upon you to end the investigation and issue a public statement, in which you retract your most recent statements, and clarify publicly that Professor Jarrar has the right and freedom to express her opinions however disagreeable they may be to some. We encourage you to turn this into a teachable moment by organizing a campus-wide forum to explain the meanings of freedom of speech and indeed academic freedom, clarifying that universities are to develop and safeguard critical independent thought.
We look forward to your response.
California Scholars for Academic Freedom
Contact Persons:
Nancy Gallagher
Research Professor of History
University of California, Santa Barbara
[email protected]
Sondra Hale
Research Professor
Anthropology and Gender Studies
University of California, Los Angeles
[email protected]
Vida Samiian
Professor and Dean Emerita
Department of Linguistics
California State University, Fresno
[email protected]
Cc Provost Lynette Zelezny
Dean Saul Jimenez-Sandoval
Take Action
- Send President Castro Your Opinion
Feedback for President Castro
"...tell me areas you think we need to improve, and your ideas of how to do that. You can do this easily and anonymously on this site. We’ll compile the ideas and publish them so we can continue the dialogue on making Fresno State an even better University." ~ President Castro - Call The Office of the President: 559-278-2324
Thank you for being one of the powerful!
People Power Can change the world!